Palmer inquiry not good enough – it’s time for action to end detention Vanstone should resign with Farmer
RAC media release, May 27 2005
Initial reports of the findings of the Palmer inquiry seem to confirm
the fears of refugee groups that it would both superficial and a
cover-up.
“The Palmer enquiry shows every indication of being the waste of time
and money we expected,” said Ian Rintoul, spokesperson for the Refugee
Action Coalition. “As an exercise in damage control for the government,
it is also a failure. The time for bandaids has gone. It is even more
important that Labor gets behind the private members bills to at least
make a start on some real change to the treatment of refugees.”
“The findings revealed so far do nothing more than state the obvious.
The government has spent hundreds of thousands of dollars to find that
‘the quality of health and psychiatric care needs to be significantly
improved’! Detainees and refugee groups have been saying that for
years. The government should stop playing politics with peoples lives
and announce the release all the asylum seekers in detention –
including Nauru and Christmas Island.”
“The report will announce the need for better health care when it is
abundantly obvious that it is detention itself that is making people
sick,” said Ian Rintoul.
“As for establishing yet another body to review detention, this is the
last thing that is needed. Bodies such as the Human Rights Commission,
the Ombudsman, and the Independent Detention Advisory Group as well as
various parliamentary committees have all issued damning reports of
detention conditions and the government’s refugee policy over the past
few years – and they have all been completely ignored.”
According to press reports, an Immigration department sourced says that
the Palmer inquiry has found that the Baxter management unit ‘had been
used inappropriately to control and punish detainees.’ “Who is going to
take responsibility for the abuse inflicted on Cornelia Rau, Vivian
Solon and the thousands of refugees who suffered behind the razor wire?
“It is all well and good to call for the removal of the head of the
immigration department, Bill Farmer. But Bill Farmer has been
implementing government policy. The government is looking for a
scapegoat. It is minister Vanstone and former minister Ruddock who are
politically responsible.
“The report will redouble the calls for an independent judicial inquiry
into the immigration department. Nothing less can restore any
confidence that the horrors that have been revealed are not going to be
repeated.”
For more information, contact Ian Rintoul .
|